Environmental Science

The Carbon Footprint of Indoor Cannabis Depends on Its ZIP Code

·

Green rows of cannabis plants beneath glasshouse lights, steel trusses and large silver ventilation ducts.

Move an imagined indoor cannabis facility from Long Beach, California, to Kaneohe Bay, Hawaii. Keep the kind of building, the product and the rules of the calculation the same. In a published model, the footprint of a kilogram of dried flower more than doubled between those locations. What did the coast of California have that the Hawaiian site did not? The answer involves both the air outside the building and the generators that supply its electricity.

A building buys two things from its surroundings

An indoor facility draws electrical energy to power equipment and maintain an interior climate. The weather determines how much work that climate control must do. Outside air can arrive hot, cold, dry or laden with moisture. Removing heat and removing water vapor are related but distinct tasks. A mild outdoor temperature does not necessarily imply a small demand for conditioning if the incoming air is humid.

Electricity has a geographical history of its own. Generating one kilowatt-hour on a grid with a greater share of fossil generation generally produces more greenhouse gas emissions than generating it on a grid with lower-carbon sources. A facility can therefore have high electricity demand and relatively low emissions per unit of electricity, or the reverse. The two influences should be calculated separately before being combined.

In their US life-cycle analysis of indoor cannabis production, Hailey Summers, Evan Sproul and Jason Quinn modeled facilities under location-specific conditions. Their estimates ranged from 2,283 to 5,184 kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent for each kilogram of dried flower. Long Beach and Kaneohe Bay marked the ends of the modeled range. These were scenario results for the facilities represented in the study. They were not inspections showing that every seller in one city had half the footprint of every seller in the other.

Why a ZIP code is a clue

A postal code is easy to look up. An electrical system does not follow postal boundaries, and electricity from a household socket does not carry the name of the power plant that generated it. The US Environmental Protection Agency’s Power Profiler uses location to connect users with the regional mix of generation. Its guidance on estimating emissions from electricity explains how regional emissions rates are applied. A regional average supports comparisons on a consistent basis. It cannot describe every hour of every facility’s electricity use.

Carbon per kilogram needs two measurements

Suppose two hypothetical buildings each generate the same annual emissions. One delivers twice as much usable dried product. Its calculated emissions per kilogram will be half as high, despite an identical annual footprint. Conversely, a building could improve its footprint per kilogram while increasing its annual emissions if its total production increased enough. Either number can be reported accurately while answering a different question.

Earlier research on the energy cost of indoor production identified lighting and environmental control as important parts of the account. In a life-cycle model, investigators also choose where to draw the boundary. The later US study followed inputs and emissions through the production stage. A customer’s journey to the shop, for example, belongs to a different portion of the product’s history. Comparisons are cleanest when the boundary as well as the denominator matches.

A map with a date on it

Regional grids change as generators open, close or change how often they operate. Buildings differ in design, operating conditions and actual output. A Colorado environmental practices guide describes the equipment choices hidden inside that single word, “facility.” A map based on one set of assumptions can explain an underlying pattern without serving as a current inventory of real facilities. To update the picture, a researcher would want metered energy use, local emissions factors for the relevant period and a measured quantity of finished product.

The two coastal cities make a useful pair precisely because neither climate nor electricity mix is obvious from the word “coastal.” The modeled difference emerges only after tracing both chains all the way back from one kilogram of flower to a building, its weather and the grid behind its meter.